Quote Originally Posted by Murugan View Post
Did you only play WoW? Why can't you read my response to you on this exact subject four posts up? I said that yes simply having anything except a personal loot list system would solve my problem as long as we could regain control over loot distribution.

Need for Greed however refers to a specific type of loot system where a dialogue box appears allowing you to "need" or "greed", and need option is often locked to the class you are on. This would not work for FFXIV. Any loot system is not called Need for Greed unless your only point of reference is WoW. Honestly... we always had a loot list in this game and we could pass stuff just fine. I'd be fine with that. We never had any problems with it because we are an organized LS which trusts all of its members. Now for people who don't have that luxury a master looter, or need for greed system, or various other types of loot options could be beneficial.

For us? It doesn't matter. We dealt with loot long ago, and we were doing just fine until Ifrit and his moronic loot implementation.
I know what Need or Greed is. I played WoW extensively. No need to imply that I don't understand what it is. If player A has Lancer, Marauder, and Archer 50, and goes to an event on Lancer, he should be able to Need on gear for all 3. I understand you're saying it wouldn't work because of the class system, a player with all classes rank 50 could Need on everything OR only Need on gear for his current class (both ways have flaws). How about a player gets to designate his top 2 or 3 classes to Need for?