Quote Originally Posted by Karshan View Post
I like the idea, but too many stacks (2.17% permanent buff ? With a 24 000 group DPS it's 520 raid DPS, way too much for just one guy to bring).

What could be would be that Ice IV has two effects : 3 umbral hearts for you, and three umbral stacks on the boss, that would work kinda like embolden but in debuff and for all kind of damage.
3 stacks, each stack is a 1% vulne and one stack fades off every 3 seconds (3% > 2% > 1%), so it would be something like 2% average debuff on what, 30% uptime (9sec every 30), which is a 0,6% raid buff (2.5 times more than devotion)

Plus it would adress the problem of gong back to arr rotation, since it would be on Ice 4

A ~2% raid increase isn't too much for one guy. Ninja brings more that with Trick Attack alone, not to mention the enmity tools and slash resist for the tanks to do more dps.