I can see that we're not going to change minds on this. My idea of job identity is not just my actions. It's also how you appear to others. After having been through this exact situation in WoW, where it was frustrating and depressing to have literally nothing unique to your class other than the spells on your bars, I'd hate to see it happen in this game too. But I can see nobody's mind is going to change on that. Luckily, both sides of the "debate" are valid opinions.