Role Feedback: Tank

[Kaisinel]

I think you missed a section in my previous post where I said both PLD/DRK can also stop such situations, if they can or even require the debuff to happen. Reducing healing overall creates more situations of sustained burst/damage becoming to overwhelming to keep up resulting in a kill. Where warrior requires the stars to align for the 10% extra damage on a target currently receiving heals to outright die. Let's not forget that DRK also has sole survivor. This isn't the same game as before like you mentioned before, not everyone has the burst to outright solo someone assuming opposing healer isn't "stunned/silence".

I won't be able to convince you, and you won't change my opinion. So just stop trying and let's get back to how weak WAR is.

[Praesul]

I think you missed a section in my previous post where I said both PLD/DRK can also stop such situations, if they can or even require the debuff to happen. Reducing healing overall creates more situations of sustained burst/damage becoming to overwhelming to keep up resulting in a kill. Where warrior requires the stars to align for the 10% extra damage on a target currently receiving heals to outright die. Let's not forget that DRK also has sole survivor. This isn't the same game as before like you mentioned before, not everyone has the burst to outright solo someone assuming opposing healer isn't "stunned/silence".

I won't be able to convince you, and you won't change my opinion. So just stop trying and let's get back to how weak WAR is.

Sole survivor has a cooldown, butcher's block does not. Also, power slash doesn't reduce healer output, it reduces healing received on the target, so no it does not lower the powerhouse's healing by 20%.

WAR's personal damage + group damage contribution beats out the other two. If you want to buff WAR damage then go ahead, but it'd have to be very minor. Their damage is not the issue, literally no one complains about their damage. Their problem is their cc being tied to their resource and invulnerability. Freeing up the gauge cost on Onslaught indirectly increases a WAR's damage output while still giving them stronger CC. Then they need some sustain, and how they're going to go about that I don't know, but a heal on storm's path would be a nice start.

You know, tank stuff, stuff that allows them to be a tank and not a DPS with 15k HP.