Personally, I think the long-coat is a step in a better direction, though, shame on me for not reading the fine print of the contest, although I did come in on the tail end of it.
Nevertheless, I am more than satisfied with a long-coat of sorts in lieu of any item that looks like a robe. It seems as though we healers are doomed to just get robe after robe after robe into infinity, which after 6+ years of being a healer main, is quite exhausting.
While I'll admit that the Lost Allagan set isn't what I would consider the best, I'll settle for that as long as we're not getting another robe.