CNJ = WHM and THM = BLM

[Inaaca]

So your agreeing that Scourge and banish are elmental based or claiming they are not ?

Um... The fact that I made an analogy against it and that I just said that the analogy refuted your point... I thought it would be clear that, no, we don't agree.

[Wynn]

Nobody is even debating what is or what isn't. Just discussing why we agree or disagree. Some people just immediately start frothing at the mouth if someone doesn't share their views.

[Coglin]

Oh i see, so you made a color analogy.....oh...thats justifies everything.....I will get the devs on the line and tell them they did it wrong because the 3 of you disagree with the entire rest of the population....I am sure that will bring them too the light....

You made an incorrect assumption.....you feel the need to justify that assumption....fine..I get that.....don't try to press it on us then get angry when we disagree.....

The lore for WHM and BLM is not in game and will be added when they add the jobs.....so lore debate becomes iffy at best with that in mind.

The only truely inherent spells that CON has that are not WHM is the elemental nukes. Every other spell is on WHM in one previous FF game or another......Pretty much every spell that THM has is on BLM in one FF game or another as well....

Wynn, your the one frothing at the mouth...you even got drool on my sig......nasty.

[MartaDemireux]

However if one were to really think about it THM looks a lot more like a BLM than CNJ does.

Not sure if you meant literally looks but if so I disagree. THM's in the THM guild are decked out in cowls and metal scepters - White Mages wear hooded robes and traditionally wield metal hammers. CNJ's in the CNJ guild wear robes and pointed hats with sagging points and wield wooden staves - Black Mages wear robes with pointed hats, sometimes with sagging points and wield wooden staves. With that in mind, the new cowl's added into the game support healing magic + while the sagging pointed hats and robes combo support magic attack.

[Inaaca]

Oh i see, so you made a color analogy.....oh...thats justifies everything.....I will get the devs on the line and tell them they did it wrong because the 3 of you disagree with the entire rest of the population....I am sure that will bring them too the light....

Did I direct the analogy at the devs? I did not. Did I argue that CNJ/THM didn't get the right jobs? I did not.

I merely addressed your argument that astral/umbral magic was somehow more "elemental" than fire/earth/wind/water/ice/lightning magic. Nothing more.

[Coglin]

Did I direct the analogy at the devs? I did not. Did I argue that CNJ/THM didn't get the right jobs? I did not.

I merely addressed your argument that astral/umbral magic was somehow more "elemental" than fire/earth/wind/water/ice/lightning magic. Nothing more.

Yes you do lie alot don't you?

feel free to quote whre I said it is "more" elemental. I asked a question, I never stated one spell was more elemental then another. Again you rearrange words and in an attempt to promote someone elses words as something else.

I simply said pointed out that THM nukes are elemental based as well.

[Wynn]

Yes you do lie alot don't you?

feel free to quote whre I said it is "more" elemental. I asked a question, I never stated one spell was more elemental then another. Again you rearrange words and in an attempt to promote someone elses words as something else.

I simply said pointed out that THM nukes are elemental based as well.

here you go

whats more elemetal then having 3 elements in 1?

[Coglin]

Again you need a dictionary.......look up "statement".... then ...look up "question".....
then compare your answer.

Again, in true liars fasion, you post a question I asked and attept you claim it as a statement.

[Inaaca]

Again you need a dictionary.......look up "statement".... then ...look up "question".....
then compare your answer.

Again, in true liars fasion, you post a question I asked and attept you claim it as a statement.

Wow, you're pulling at straws and backpeddling quite a bit here.

Say what you want, but question or not, you clearly phrased your question to emphasize in favor of THM spells being more elemental. You were challenging others to come up with something "more elemental than having 3 elements in 1." So we took up that challenge.

This is clear, anyone can see it, so stop trying to change your stance and stand by your own words.

[Wynn]

Again you need a dictionary.......look up "statement".... then ...look up "question".....
then compare your answer.

Again, in true liars fasion, you post a question I asked and attept you claim it as a statement.

You do realize that people can read what you wrote (assuming you don't edit that post as you are prone to do) and glean the context from it, right? Sure, it was a question. A rhetorical one.