balance through Balance

[MsTanya]

I'm gonna try my hand at mathing potencies. Lets assume criticals are about 1.4x modifier since they got reduced.

Adlo is 300 base heal and shield goes up to 420 potency heal 840 potency shield on a crit. Aspected benefic is 200 base potency with a 1.15 modifier on noct sect so 230 base and has a 250% shield for 575 base shield on a crit however its a 332 potency heal and a 805 potency shield. So adlo only really wins on heal potency and even a critlo is nearly equal to a crit aspbene. Mp cost is 1800 adlo versus 1440 asp bene plus insta cast versus cast time, adlo loses there too.

We see an even bigger disparity with helios. 150 potency succor shield and heal both, 210 on a crit. 150x1.15=172 potency helios with a 150% shield of 258 potency so base helios beats crit succor...and for 1800 mp versus succors 2280. Ingame on my lvl 70 ast that's a 4700 aoe shield on a non crit with an i300 weapon, only beatable by deploy, if it crits that's a 7000 shield on whoever it crits on effectively beating everything but a critlo, and that's an on demand heal, not a two minute cooldown.

So how are scholars ahead on mitigation again?