If you have a card from a raid, you should only be allowed to roll greed

[Bacent]

Then how about once a card is traded from player to player once, it is unable to be resold or traded again.

No? That would still get people to be selling MGP to other players. Cards can stack. So if you manage to get a full stack of cards, you could sell X amount of MGP for Y amount of Gil.

Our need for MGP is just as important. I vote no, let us roll like normal.

MGP is a lot easier to get than some of the cards, even more so when you have a super low chance of getting a card you don't yet have because of people going 'I need MGP who cares about people who actually need it'.

So personally, I don't see the 'need' for MGP to be as important as people trying to collect items they actually need, and getting blocked off by people who already have it. This used to happen when horse farming, where people could actually roll on another whistle when they already had one. I reported many people at the time who even said in the chat 'Oh I only rolled cause I could lol', in which this kept happening up until you could no longer roll for what you already had.

People should not be prevented from getting what they're trying to get by people who already have the same item.

[DaikiKiyoshi]

No? That would still get people to be selling MGP to other players. Cards can stack. So if you manage to get a full stack of cards, you could sell X amount of MGP for Y amount of Gil.



MGP is a lot easier to get than some of the cards, even more so when you have a super low chance of getting a card you don't yet have because of people going 'I need MGP who cares about people who actually need it'.

So personally, I don't see the 'need' for MGP to be as important as people trying to collect items they actually need, and getting blocked off by people who already have it. This used to happen when horse farming, where people could actually roll on another whistle when they already had one. I reported many people at the time who even said in the chat 'Oh I only rolled cause I could lol', in which this kept happening up until you could no longer roll for what you already had.

People should not be prevented from getting what they're trying to get by people who already have the same item.

You keep using that phrase, "That they actually need...". Well some people actually need MGP. Why should someone "needing" the card be more important than someone "needing" MGP? Who gets to make that judgement call? Because it seems to be a matter of opinion and I vote they are both equally "needed" and to leave the rolling system alone on this one. Everyone being able to roll need still gives everyone an equal chance at getting it. Fair is fair.