Role Skills a Mistake?

[Reynhart]

PLD can pick more of the "good stuff" since they already have those skills innately. Depends entirely on the execution of the system.

How I understand that system is those skills will not be innate PLD anymore, they'll be in a pool, with skills either available right from the start (But in a limited number depending on your level), or learn by every tank at the same level.

However, if they go as far as to make a special pool where you have to chose your additionnal skills, maybe we'll see more interesting choices. If it's only to make Provoke available, why not simply giving it as a native skill for all tanks with different names ? After all, every healer already has its variation of Raise or Esuna.