But if the Devs want us to speculate about it instead of just saying "she is a monk/she is something else" than isnt this whole tread contra productive because the thread wants us to stop speculating on it?

I am not really a final fantasy fan since I only played two games of the franchise so I am not familiar with dancer. I would be okay if she is a dancer of if she is a monk but I always find a nice speculation fun.

After reading through the thread both sides makes sense in some way so I am kinda looking forward to knowing who was right in the end. It was kinda telling, watching a life reaction to the trailer, that a lot of people cheered when they saw the girl at the beginning, so its seems that it was done that way to create such a reaction. If it was just out of a little trolling fun or because it was a tease for things to come will be seen.