Forcing NA Duty Finder to be better, we need a grading system.

[MihaelB]

Problem is this isn't a professional league with stringent rules and metrics you're expected to earn. It's a game. If someone wanted to play in a soccer league, and signed up with their local one, and chose not to practice between games likely wouldn't be kicked out completely (depends on the league and level of professionalism).

(going to ignore the whole last half of your post because that's just being extreme for the sake of being extreme. People like THAT are so far less than 1% of 1%, you might run into them once a year)

Two years ago, maybe once during that whole first year of me playing but I wasn't anywhere near high level duty correlation. Now that I've been level 60 for around another year, it's almost every second day I see someone with abysmal DPS.

If the rules let me post all the records I have, you'll know it's not an exaggeration. There are hundreds of records where DPS roles do less DPS than tank and healer. The records can't unfortunately show you whether they're mentors too which a large estimation of 30% in my personal records are.

[Snugglebutt]

If the rules let me post all the records I have, you'll know it's not an exaggeration. There are hundreds of records where DPS roles do less DPS than tank and healer. The records can't unfortunately show you whether they're mentors too which a large estimation of 30% in my personal records are.

Sure..sure...and I am a Nigerian prince with a cheque for a billion pounds to deposit in your bank account. Truth is this is your thread and your attempt to get your suggested grading system added to the game, you will say anything to try and make that happen including exaggerate things to add fictional weight to your position in order to swing the scales in your favor.

[hagare]

Two years ago, maybe once during that whole first year of me playing but I wasn't anywhere near high level duty correlation. Now that I've been level 60 for around another year, it's almost every second day I see someone with abysmal DPS.

If the rules let me post all the records I have, you'll know it's not an exaggeration. There are hundreds of records where DPS roles do less DPS than tank and healer. The records can't unfortunately show you whether they're mentors too which a large estimation of 30% in my personal records are.

do you have a record of smooth runs as well?

[MihaelB]

do you have a record of smooth runs as well?

Yes, I'd say it's a smooth run if there's no pain threshold in tanking/healing due to low level gearing or if there isn't a wipe which would be the majority.