Eastern Cherry Trees

[Dustytome]

They'll remain in the game for the event

Except they don't come back with the event. I know many people including myself were waiting until the last stage of the event in hopes the trees would be purchasable from the vendor and they were not.

[Beckett]

They'll remain in the game for the event

But they won't, though. SE hasn't had any event furnishings available for re-purchase, not even fixtures like the Bombard Lantern or Eerie Wallpaper that get destroyed if you replace them. If the event furnishings were available for purchase at the following year's event, the vast majority wouldn't be complaining about this issue.

[Lexia]

Undercutting wouldn't make it any less P2W, though. You're still trading an item spent with IRL currency for in-game currency, which can be used to purchase runs to obtain better gear.

Like this doesn't already happen with mog shop items so how would the trees be any different?

[Zigabar]

Like this doesn't already happen with mog shop items so how would the trees be any different?

It wouldn't. As I said before:

They could make the Mogstation ones Market Board Prohibited, like the other furnishing in the MS, and leave the ones currently in game as they are, like the dyes.

True. I wasn't saying otherwise. People currently do this now with the furnishings on Mogstation. The above option would just eliminate direct MB RMT, while allowing those currently in game to continue to sell.

That does, however, break ToS. So, like selling houses/MS furnishings, people would need to get crafty to sell the Trees, as PF adverts would be reportable.

I've already answered your question.

[worldofneil]

Like this doesn't already happen with mog shop items so how would the trees be any different?

Only the items that were untradeable get sold later on the mogstation. The trees in question are not only tradeable, but also market board sellable. It's like the Paramour Barding from the Valentines 2015 event never came back (in game or on Mogstation) because it is also tradeable and sellable.

It's probably because of the whole mess with the Eternity Rings where people were selling them in game for gil that they don't now sell anything on the mogstation that is tradeable.

[NorthernLadMSP]

That issue was already addressed. All they have to do is add the Market Prohibited/Untradeable tag to them just like they did when they added all the dyes - that way said person can buy as many as they want for their house, but cannot sell or trade them.

[Lexia]

It's probably because of the whole mess with the Eternity Rings where people were selling them in game for gil that they don't now sell anything on the mogstation that is tradeable.

People still sell mog station items instead of trading in game person just trades gil and then person sends them the redeem code.

[Vexander]

Except they don't come back with the event. I know many people including myself were waiting until the last stage of the event in hopes the trees would be purchasable from the vendor and they were not.

That's a different matter then. They should be added back into the event. And still made Mog Station purchasable.

[Nox_Shinya]

NO Mog Station

Stop asking for things to be put in the MS and ask them to be put IN THE GAME, seriously....we all pay a sub, we should all be abble to get EVERY content without having to pay extra € for that....this is NOT a F2P

No, it should be put in the mogstation. Why? Because I paid for the game subscription when the Cherry Tree event was around, so that I could get a Cherry tree. People that weren't around back then didn't pay for the sub, so why should they get them item that I had to pay for?

Of course, I don't really think like that and I don't care if they mogstation the item or not. But the point I'm trying to make is that you are not entitled to a limited item just because you pay a sub now, when you didn't pay for a sub back then. That's why it's limited and that's why some people think it should stay that way

[Vexander]

Put it on the Mog Station. I'd rather SE earned money from it and cycled it back into making the game great, than leaving it as this limited item that's in high demand but will never be given more supply. It's just a waste of assets. Even if it was $1 a tree on the Mog Station, SE would be making a pretty penny.