I would have liked it. I have experience playing another MMO and I had no use for tanking when their damage output was so pathetic, like 20-25% what a DPS was capable of. When I started playing FFXIV I loved how tanks weren't swinging wet noodles for a change and I actually ENJOYED tanking (which I had to do, because I only use swords and PLD/DRK are my favorite classes in the game) but sadly after coming back to the game I didn't get to 60 before the nerfhammer fell.