Petition Against Ifrit Weapon Designs

[Xionraserei]

This is the original post in the thread:



There are no 'technical comments' in this post. There's nothing about programming, modeling, or databases. Just a lot of whining about how the OP doesn't agree with the way the items look, because it looks 'too Korean,' as if that's a valid complaint.

Or maybe you could point out the sophisticated, designer-helpful feedback that was in that post? 'cause, all I see is several sentences of whining and puling because SE designed some weapons that some people don't like.

How you fail to get anything from that furthers my stance of being part of the uncreative majority (creative being design people). Saying that they look too korean says a lot actually if your familiar with korean MMOs then you would absolutely understand where I am coming from. So I also assume now your not familiar with them. It is a totally valid comment.

Maybe I am using too many specific terms intended for people in the know. Which sometimes I am guilty of. I am of course talking to everyone and not just people in the correct areas. But I ask people try to understand before or ask questions. Within the frustration, as ive said, there are more than enough valid points.

[Cycloptichorn]

How you fail to get anything from that furthers my stance of being part of the uncreative majority (creative being design people). Saying that they look too korean says a lot actually if your familiar with korean MMOs then you would absolutely understand where I am coming from. So I also assume now your not familiar with them. It is a totally valid comment.

Why is it that you feel so free to make assumptions about people you don't even know?

I write for a living. Do you consider that to be creative? Would you like me to come back atcha with some helpful criticism as to how you could improve your writing skills (which, frankly, seem to be a little lacking)? Would you feel pretty good about that sort of feedback? It's the equivalent of what you are doing here.

I am quite familiar with Korean MMO's, thank you very much. I just don't have a problem with them the way that you seem to. It's a video game, man. Not reality. The fact that some things look more unrealistic than others is to be expected, not something to pitch a fit over.

I have little doubt that I've been playing games since before you were born... we didn't used to have the luxury of bitching at devs because we don't like the way one weapon looks. You suck it up and move on. Maybe that's why I think you're being rude here.

[Xionraserei]

Why is it that you feel so free to make assumptions about people you don't even know?

I write for a living. Do you consider that to be creative? Would you like me to come back atcha with some helpful criticism as to how you could improve your writing skills (which, frankly, seem to be a little lacking)? Would you feel pretty good about that sort of feedback? It's the equivalent of what you are doing here.

I am quite familiar with Korean MMO's, thank you very much. I just don't have a problem with them the way that you seem to. It's a video game, man. Not reality. The fact that some things look more unrealistic than others is to be expected, not something to pitch a fit over.

I have little doubt that I've been playing games since before you were born... we didn't used to have the luxury of bitching at devs because we don't like the way one weapon looks. You suck it up and move on. Maybe that's why I think you're being rude here.

Actually, No. Writing is not a creative position in the sense of design. Writing falls under a different field. I would not take a writers comment as a design comment. I'd take them as a normal individuals comment if it is a design related issue. If it was on another subject I would take your comment as an educated opinion.

"I am quite familiar with Korean MMO's, thank you very much. I just don't have a problem with them the way that you seem to. It's a video game, man. Not reality. The fact that some things look more unrealistic than others is to be expected, not something to pitch a fit over."

- Then you would understand that they are vastly different than Final Fantasy Titles in terms of design and have a specific catagory within MMO classifications and would have agree'd with me.

"I have little doubt that I've been playing games since before you were born... we didn't used to have the luxury of bitching at devs because we don't like the way one weapon looks. You suck it up and move on. Maybe that's why I think you're being rude here."

We'll you didn't have MMOs then or fancy graphics now did you? Theres more involved these days than your imagination.

i wont even elaborate on your off-topic banter about my writing. Left field? (yes that's a lowercase i)