
Originally Posted by
Kaurie
No, I have already explained my post, but I guess you don't want to go back a few pages to see - or you missed it, fair enough.
It's stupid, because it doesn't actually add any content for crafters, it's not making things more engaging for them. It is merely requiring them to make a relatively easy craft, so they can make millions of gil transferred to them by people who don't craft. It's argued that it makes crafting relevant again, but it doesn't. It makes a handful of random items useful, but not crafting as a whole. It's not engaging, it's not content, it's not fun, it's only a way to transfer gil from some players to another.
I don't have crafters or gatherers, because I personally think the implementation in this game of crafting and gathering is abysmal. I've never seen something less fun in a video game before. I talked to people to determine if it improves at higher levels, but everything that I hate about it is actually amplified at higher levels rather than reduced. Regardless of this, it's irrelevant to the conversation.
TLDR What is stupid is that this doesn't add anything of substance, and that it's an unnecessary gil transfer.