As a new player, I was touched by the Starlight Celebration. The tale of the Ishgardian knights sneaking orphans into their barracks, etc... which is why the Saint and his little helpers wear red coats has so much more depth than our own Santa Claus who wears red because of a Coke-a-Cola ad campaign. I liked the bit about the bell, too. Overall, I enjoyed the celebration because of it's simplicity. Now, I understand why you veteran players are like "meh." But, to a newbie, it was nice.
Looking forward to next year, I hope there is something in Ishgard to bring the whole tale full circle. Maybe a quest to help the descendants or the original orphans save a new generation of orphans. There could be fates where we have to protect the orphans from attack as we move them to shelter or maybe assist Hilde- I mean- the Saint of Nymeia in some manner.