Dark Knight or Warrior?

[Freyyy]

WAR is missing the -20% Damage taken that DRK/PLD has

Stop. You're so wrong on this. +25% more HP is the exact same thing as -20% less damage taken in terms of eHP. The exact same thing. Only the healing part is inferior, Defiance would need to give about 25% more healing received to be completely equal to ShO/Grit, but those missing 4-5% are easily compensated by the huge amount of self-healing a WAR has.

And Inner Beast is easily the best defensive ability in the game. Building 5 stacks takes between 16 and 21 seconds basically. You can have IB litteraly anytime you want and need it with knowledge of the fight. Vengeance is also the best defensive CD in the game without taking HG into account. And also, Storm's Eye and Storm's Path. Nuff said. Stop comparing WAR with the other 2, it's not even the same thing.

[Martin_Arcainess]

Stop. You're so wrong on this. +25% more HP is the exact same thing as -20% less damage taken in terms of eHP. The exact same thing. Only the healing part is inferior, Defiance would need to give about 25% more healing received to be completely equal to ShO/Grit, but those missing 4-5% are easily compensated by the huge amount of self-healing a WAR has.

etc due to limit

Yeah but the main point i'm trying to make that DRK can reduce more Magic damage that a WAR.

Don't get your fingers in a twist

[Tyrial]

Yeah but the main point i'm trying to make that DRK can reduce more Magic damage that a WAR.

Don't get your fingers in a twist

That's a nice ninja edit to completely change your post. To answer your question (yes, the one you edited out):

PLD was taken in solo tank situations primarily due to the fact that their CDs allowed groups to completely negate specific mechanics.

[Martin_Arcainess]

That's a nice ninja edit to completely change your post. To answer your question (yes, the one you edited out):

PLD was taken in solo tank situations primarily due to the fact that their CDs allowed groups to completely negate specific mechanics.

Lol I thought I best keep it on track and not go off in a different direction. Plus cooking posting on forums is never a good idea.

Edit:

And also the fact I didn't want to write a big massive post only for it to say sorry 1000 character post limit.

For the WAR VS PLD tank stance multi hits is where PLD was great at and even WAR's added HP and Healing received could not comprehend.

So for Example one of them was T9 Bahamut's Claw.

PLD: 9,000 HP takes 5 Bahamut Claw hits at 3,000 Damage as the standard damage, thanks to PLD's Tank stance it takes 2,400 per hit 5 x 2,400 = 12,000 damage

WAR: 9,000 HP +25% 11,250 3,000 x 5 = 15,000 damage.

So where as the Healer would heal more on PLD but even the PLD's shield could reduce the incoming damage by another 22%. *combine with bulk increase chance of shield blocking by 80%*

WAR has some nice Defensive Cool downs but not the best. All of them have the pros and cons, Innerbeast is a awesome skill but PLD's got it's Shieldon now which is only a 30 sec CD and doesn't cost a GCD.

[Freyyy]

snip

That's the dumbest maths I've ever seen. If the PLD has 9.000 HP, the WAR has 11250, not 9000.

[Martin_Arcainess]

That's the dumbest maths I've ever seen. If the PLD has 9.000 HP, the WAR has 11250, not 9000.

Wow you really are touchy today aint ya? just calm down a litttle ok Freyy? no need to blow a basket.

Anyway that was based on them having the same gear so duh they both would have 9K HP but since you didn't read all my post you missed out the +25% HP making it 11,250.

and in case you missed it again I shall bold it for you \o/

Lol I thought I best keep it on track and not go off in a different direction. Plus cooking posting on forums is never a good idea.

Edit:

And also the fact I didn't want to write a big massive post only for it to say sorry 1000 character post limit.

For the WAR VS PLD tank stance multi hits is where PLD was great at and even WAR's added HP and Healing received could not comprehend.

So for Example one of them was T9 Bahamut's Claw.

PLD: 9,000 HP takes 5 Bahamut Claw hits at 3,000 Damage as the standard damage, thanks to PLD's Tank stance it takes 2,400 per hit 5 x 2,400 = 12,000 damage

WAR: 9,000 HP +25% 11,250 3,000 x 5 = 15,000 damage.

So where as the Healer would heal more on PLD but even the PLD's shield could reduce the incoming damage by another 22%. *combine with bulk increase chance of shield blocking by 80%*

WAR has some nice Defensive Cool downs but not the best. All of them have the pros and cons, Innerbeast is a awesome skill but PLD's got it's Shieldon now which is only a 30 sec CD and doesn't cost a GCD.

true not the most detailed but you get the idea.......right?

Lol at anyone trying to say that WAR isn't mandatory for raids.

WAR is the most complete tank in the game and has ZERO downsides. DrK is good but has flaws. If you are endgame raiding and looking for a static then go with WAR. If you are just casually playing then go with whatever feels the best.

What are DRK's Flaws?

[rhett]

no need to blow a basket.

Did............did you mean gasket?

[Freyyy]

snip

Thank you Mr. NinjaEdit. That's smart of you to edit your post 2min before answering to me. The "+25% HP 11250" part was non existent the first time I read your answer. I'll just say that now with your edit, your maths are only showing that I'm completely right when I'm saying that Defiance = ShO in terms of effective HP. I'll never argue with you again, you're a troll.