The issue nobody wants to address

[Fevelle]

So you are saying it is fine if someone goes semi AFK and just autop attacks the mobs while the rest of the party do all the effort, added in fact to clear the content? What if it's the tank who does that? Or the healer? If DPS are allowed to play half assed then the other roles should have a free pass to do so also.

Going semi-afk isn't playing at all. What I'm saying is that if someone isn't on top of their rotations or DPS, but can still pull enough to clear the content without embarassing anyone, there's no need to pick on them or label them bad just because they have place for improvement, the same goes for healers and tanks.