If Paladin is "specialized in defense" shouldn't its defense be better always?

[Anger]

EDIT 2: I watched your A2S for funzies. How do you find these videos of such baddies? Are you intentionally looking for the worst examples possible? WAR doing 800 DPS in that fight is blasphemy! Lol.... I have videos of WARs doing over 1020 from 3 weeks ago (ilv190 weapon).

Essentially, every video on YouTube with a Paladin losing by much more than 5% as you previously stated, you will label a "baddie?" You do realize that there are TONS of these videos on YouTube blatantly showing a 20 - 30% damage lead in favor of the Warrior with few, if any, showing the Warrior losing the DPS race or that the percentage is within 5%.

You can look on YouTube for your self and call them all "baddies" if you'd like but there is a blatant truth that Warrior can do much, much greater damage than a Paladin and still tank the same fight with just as much ease.

Remember your entire analysis is surrounding YOUR personal experience. You need to look beyond that and realize that not everyone is going to be a "pro player" but that doesn't change the fact that the Warrior has a significant damage advantage. In essence, if the same skill level is applied to both classes the warrior will always lead DPS and tank just as well.

At this point, you're basically arguing what color the sky is and I'm saying it's blue.