Why so much hate for job/class ideas?

[Julienne]

It seems to me that when someone throws out a new idea for a job or class, spends a great deal of time fleshing out their idea, and obviously worked really hard on it, they should be given constructive criticism. Instead, all I see are people saying,

"Terrible"

"This idea sucks"

"This will never happen because reasons"

Way to discourage the creative mind, people. If you don't have something nice to say, don't say it at all.

[Tanathya]

Agreed!
/10char

[Ferrasper]

This idea will never happen because reasons is constructive criticism. They are telling them why it won't work. There is nothing wrong with being honest about it instead of trying to put on a false front knowing it won't work.

[XgungraveX]

because its not the red mage job

[Mikhaill]

You must've saw the Vampire and Beast Master topics too, right?
I get really upset because Mimilu [The Vampire OP.]
Usually has really good idea's and that's the first time s/he has actually, from what I saw, put down on his idea's.
It's annoying when people even try to flesh out stuff and of course people on this cesspool of a forum are ready to charge in lol.

[Julienne]

This idea will never happen because reasons is constructive criticism. They are telling them why it won't work. There is nothing wrong with being honest about it instead of trying to put on a false front knowing it won't work.

Did you read my whole post? There is no constructive criticism being given. People are leaving single word/sentence comments like "terrible" or "your idea sucks" with no explanation as to why they dislike the job idea.

[Julienne]

You must've saw the Vampire and Beast Master topics too, right?
I get really upset because Mimilu [The Vampire OP.]
Usually has really good idea's and that's the first time s/he has actually, from what I saw, put down on his idea's.
It's annoying when people even try to flesh out stuff and of course people on this cesspool of a forum are ready to charge in lol.

It's so sad when people work hard on something, just to have people walk all over it as if it was nothing. I wish people on these forums were more considerate.

[Ferrasper]

Did you read my whole post? There is no constructive criticism being given. People are leaving single word/sentence comments like "terrible" or "your idea sucks" with no explanation as to why they dislike the job idea.

I did read it. This won't work because reasons was the third one listed.

[Julienne]

I did read it. This won't work because reasons was the third one listed.

I meant that the reasons they give are usually asinine and childish. I probably should have put that in there.

[Ferrasper]

I meant that the reasons they give are usually asinine and childish. I probably should have put that in there.

Yes, that would help. Clarity is a good thing when it comes to this type of manner.