Emotes in the cash shop..

[Akselier]

The dyes are actually cash shop exclusive, so I think you're misinformed. Metallic red, blue, etc are not from ventures.

http://ffxiv.gamerescape.com/wiki/Quick_Exploration

[Adire]

http://ffxiv.gamerescape.com/wiki/Quick_Exploration

Jet Black Dye, Metallic Gold Dye, Metallic Silver Dye, Pastel Blue Dye, Pastel Green Dye, Pastel Pink Dye, Pastel Purple Dye, Pure White Dye, Retainer Fantasia

Tell me, do you see metallic red, metallic blue, or metallic green in that list you just linked?

You should look at the links you post before you post them >_>. You just proved yourself wrong!

[Adire]

Fine, they don't have all the dyes. But it still shows that not all the cash shop dyes are exclusive.

I never claimed all of them were

Only that they've taken their first steps into the cash-shop-exclusive-dye territory, and one of a few steps into the cash-shop-exclusive-vanity territory.

Edit: Misread your post. As Titor says below, all dyes in the cash shop are exclusive to the cash shop, and all dyes not in the cash shop are exclusive to the game.

[Akselier]

Right, that was my bad.

[Titor]

Fine, they don't have all the dyes. But it still shows that not all the cash shop dyes are exclusive.

All of the cash shop dyes /are/ exclusive. The retainer venture dyes are not in the cash shop and vice versa.

[Dynas]

You can actually get some of the cash shop metalic dyes from CUL desynth.

[Adire]

You can actually get some of the cash shop metalic dyes from CUL desynth.

Source? Never heard this before.

[Dynas]

Source? Never heard this before.

http://en.ff14angler.com/

Shows metalic dyes gained from desynths on some fish.

[Titor]

http://ffxiv.gamerescape.com/wiki/Quick_Exploration

You literally just proved that the metallic red blue green are not there. They are cash shop only. You cannot even buy them with the RaF feathers or anything.