WAR love is out of hand. Twelve forbid the other Tanks stand out in any way.

[Allyrion]

19.5% when the slashing debuff is taken into account. Which is something you should take into account when 1 job gets it natively and the other job is reliant on receiving it from an outside source. Even 19.5% is fine though as an OT.

The slashing debuff should just be considered constant regardless.
If there's no WAR, there should be a NIN.

While in some cases there might not be either, I don't think that would be the default assumption when comparing.
Either you always compare both with and without the debuff, or with the debuff as a constant since it's not exclusive to WAR.

[Ayuris]

The slashing debuff should just be considered constant regardless.
If there's no WAR, there should be a NIN.

While in some cases there might not be either, I don't think that would be the default assumption when comparing.
Either you always compare both with and without the debuff, or with the debuff as a constant since it's not exclusive to WAR.

However chances are that you wont have the same benefits of the debuff regardless of there is a warrior and/or a ninja in the party.
Take A1S for an exampe, when the second oppressor enters, the slashing debuff either stays or goes with the warrior.
Meaning even if the entire party can benefit from the debuff, only the warrior and ninja is guaranteed to have the constant benefit since it will be applied to the their targets IF they are attacking.