WAR love is out of hand. Twelve forbid the other Tanks stand out in any way.

[Kaith]

Uncontrolled tests do not provide valuable numbers. You need the exact same gear/food/composition/skill/attributes/time, and both using equally optimum rotations.

The quoted link was the same person using the same gear and food. It had PLD at 836 DPS and WAR at 1054, he has since removed the parses though.

The PLD numbers I can reproduce myself

Gear - http://i.imgur.com/CY5GO3P.jpg (The top non-meld accessory is slaying, the i176 is purely because the melded accessories are i150)
Sword Oath Parse - http://i.imgur.com/AHa7Jo0.jpg (Not a care given to maintaining enmity)
Shield Oath Parse - http://i.imgur.com/XfG5Y2S.jpg (This was rotating all 3 combos)

The next combo would have put me TP dead.

Food is just NQ Deep-Fried Okeanis (30 SkS, 10 Det) because it's what i had laying around in my invent so not optimum. Obviously slashing debuff is not present. Nor is the STR party buff.

https://youtu.be/XhLfcwsqeOE
Video of parse from pld/drk/war in their OT role same gear, all with str pt bonus, same food slashing debuff for pld/drk brought by a warrior outside of party, also goad/tp regen from machinist was used to parse all 3 over 5 mins.
For ppl too lazy to watch:
WAR 1021 dps
PLD 941 dps
DRK 970 dps

Gear can also be seen at the begin of the video

So basically that breaks down to the below I think

WAR 1021
DRK (with debuff) - 970
PLD (with debuff) - 941
DRK (without debuff) - 881
PLD (without debuff) - 855

Would need numbers when people are MT'ing to work out total composition damage. For Faust at least I did 714 DPS as PLD MT today with this gear (http://i.imgur.com/CY5GO3P.jpg). That was with Shield Oath up for 3 combos then switching to Sword Oath then switching back to Shield Oath at 6 stacks (which I could probably get away with not doing for a slight DPS increase)

Parses I've seen of MT WAR's on Faust were ~830-870 when filtered to just Faust damage but I have no idea on their gear.