I've added data points for a level 51, 52, and 57 SCH. I'll try to get the rest as I go. I also realize I should probably indicate the "+MND/DET" increase needed to match two levels so it's clear on the data sheet.

Quote Originally Posted by Irving View Post
Most of the healing changes have been noticed post 50, as in 51+. Most people are testing now due to the healing drop off observed in Eos/Selene at 51+.
It is impossible to have done said healing statistics when we did not even know of this scaling problem pre3.0.
^ Pretty much this, to answer you second question, Amaret. Unless I can turn back time, I won't be able to do those tests.

Quote Originally Posted by ckc22 View Post
IMO it's a silent nerf. They did it on purpose and were quiet about it.

My fairy used to embrace for = the heal component of adlo at pretty much all ilvls/gear.

My embrace now does about 1300 while my adlo does close to 2k heal.

Expect to get a "eff off scholars" message when they address this "accepted bug."
Funny enough, it's technically not a nerf. Looking at that data I compiled, the Fairy was always meant to grow "negatively" and the difference was to be made up in stats in the gear. If two Scholars have the same MND / Determination / MD but one is a lower level than the other, the lower level SCH will have more powerful spells and Embraces.

This seems to change when you hit post 50+ for the actual caster and is actually either staying even or getting stronger per level, but the Fairy themselves seem to stay on the same negative curve. This is where you're seeing the larger and larger divide as the two curves that were kinda in parallel pre-50 begin to part in opposing directions post-50. Admittedly, I didn't do the high level tests with a level 1 weapon, so the fact that the higher level SCH / WHM has a better cure may be because of the way the stat curve works for the weapons and will probably do some more testing some time this week, comparing my 60 WHM to a 50 WHM.

But as you say, this could just be S-E's way of "nerfing the Fairy" by not touching their growth but positively adjusting the growth of the SCH to put more emphasis on the caster versus the Fairy. Time will tell.