Quote Originally Posted by Paikis View Post
I think that a good tank is more than just his class. I would rather have a good Warrior than a mediocre Dark Knight. As long as all the tank classes can do the job, you should always pick the best players rather than the best class.
No, that doesn't mean that there should be bad class balance or design. And in serious situations, the "best" players will almost always pick the "best" class for the job. Why do you think everyone always have the PLD main tank? If you're in a serious group, especially those aiming to be first to clear contents, and you're a WAR, you're NEVER EVER gonna be main tanking until the content becomes a joke for your group, period.