Quote Originally Posted by Gunspec View Post
A problem with horizontal gear progression in FFXIV is that we ALREADY have severe trouble in terms of inventory management. Thanks to vertical progression, you can safely discard any gear you have replaced, unless you want to hold on to it for cosmetics.

With horizontal progression, you would need to keep multiple sets of gear to mix and match the secondary stats. For example, if they were to design gear to utilize elemental resistance for horizontal progression, you'd need at least 6 sets of gear on hand in order to fight the extreme primals in a row.

With vertical progression, you'll be using the same amount of storage space for your important gear in three years as you are using today. (Assuming classes continue falling in the general established categories.)
I don't really get this "multiple sets" debate, few horizontal mmo's i played, had stat caps, so all you had to do was build a template that capped all the relevant stats you needed, even though it was very difficult sometimes to find out what pieces you needed, it was very feasible to max out all stat bonuses and resistances relevant to your class.