Quote Originally Posted by Azurymber View Post
that only happens when the npc is up and for some reason it doesnt happen sometimes. LIke i was there an hour with npc up and no battle npc popped.
Quote Originally Posted by Akira View Post
the npc doesnt spawn right at horizon, when alfgar pops in uldah he tells you to go to north horizon which is up on the map from the camp itself
Precisely, Akira. The NPC spawns where the actual battle takes place, not at the camp itself. I can't get on the game right now, but for Camp Tranquil, it's the first big clearing with the river along the path north towards Gridania. The NPC spawns at the southern entrance and the Garlean soldiers come from the path along the north.

I have other people who can confirm that the timing is consistently 20-30 mins.

Thus making this entire thread pointless.