Is NIN better job than MNK?

[Skyl1n3]

That could just be assosiated to the fact those MNKs were bad, in a Single target DPS Race, a MNK will pull ahead by a good bit.

I was on full i120 and a couple i130 augmented where-as he was on majority i120 and a couple i130 Dread gear and i130 Magitek MNK weps so I'm assuming he is some-what skilled and this is throughtout World of Darkness on all bosses, I don't think it could get much fairer than that really, and we were mostly neck and neck sometimes around +/-20 difference to eachother but apart from that not much in it.

[MidlaneGod]

I was on full i120 and a couple i130 augmented where-as he was on majority i120 and a couple i130 Dread gear and i130 Magitek MNK weps so I'm assuming he is some-what skilled and this is throughtout World of Darkness on all bosses, I don't think it could get much fairer than that really, and we were mostly neck and neck sometimes around +/-20 difference to eachother but apart from that not much in it.

Most dps perform half assed rotations on 24 man content.

[Skyl1n3]

Most dps perform half assed rotations on 24 man content.

Not when you're trying to kill something as quick as possible to avoid certain wipe mechanics.

[MrSmiley]

Most dps perform half assed rotations on 24 man content.

not to mention the debuff cap messes with a lot, Ive had CT runs where my monk cannot have dragon kick debuff on a mob, it just disappears a second later.

[abzoluut]

not to mention the debuff cap messes with a lot, Ive had CT runs where my monk cannot have dragon kick debuff on a mob, it just disappears a second later.

That's because when there is another MNK, he'll apply DK too. If yours was applied first, his will overwrite yours and the third MNK will overwrite his. Most MNKs don't even know this so you should be fine to just go beast mode and skip DK. If not, just ask which one of you will do DK. Problem solved.

[Butcherboy]

I was on full i120 and a couple i130 augmented where-as he was on majority i120 and a couple i130 Dread gear and i130 Magitek MNK weps so I'm assuming he is some-what skilled and this is throughtout World of Darkness on all bosses, I don't think it could get much fairer than that really, and we were mostly neck and neck sometimes around +/-20 difference to eachother but apart from that not much in it.

Having better gear does not equal good at a job

[Skyl1n3]

Having better gear does not equal good at a job

Oh my bad, I didn't realise you had to have full Dreadwyrm gear and weapon to be certified 'good' at your Job...

[Jeckyl_Tesla]

Oh my bad, I didn't realise you had to have full Dreadwyrm gear and weapon to be certified 'good' at your Job...

It's clear you didn't understand what he meant.

Dreadwyrm gear goes not mean you're good at playing your class. I've come across multiple DRGs in Dreadwyrm who I've out-DPS'd with my worse gear compared to them. Also a NIN too. Hell, I've yet to come across somebody who has out DPS'd me (doesn't mean I'm the best, I've just come across badp layers) and a lot of them have had Dreadwyrm gear.

[Butcherboy]

Oh my bad, I didn't realise you had to have full Dreadwyrm gear and weapon to be certified 'good' at your Job...

Hmm I didn't not know tat gears are the deciding factor to be awesome at something, may be a should acquire an account with xx ilvl and call my self god..... GTFO