Should we be limited to only one craft class?

[Dargoth_Draconia]

http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/t...mer-2011/page2


In this thread it seems SE wants to limit us to only being able to level one craft class. What do you think?

I think it worked in FF11 but unless they remove the repair system in this game completely OR let the NPC repair to 100% at a reasonable price its not a good idea.

Ninja edit:
Guys please stop with the this is "pure speculation" because it was said and i quoted the thread. All im asking is are you ok with it and why?

The only thing we do not know is what will be limited. that is pure speculation but they are "thinking" about it so we can discuss it.

Without the form of making each crafter have a specialized field of work the game is kind of broken whether you guys see it or not. I think it is dumb to think you should be able to have all crafts maxed. About the repair issue I don't think every person should have the ability to repair all of their gear, I am sure they will not lower your current 50 cap crafts but they will probably allow you to take one up to the higher cap and the other be capped at 50 which would probably allow you to be able to repair most everything anyways. Sorry that is speculation but I am sure they have thought of this. I am glad that are adding only 1 capped crafting class because I believe that will actually stimulate the economy and make certain crafted pieces harder to obtain. This is like adding specializations so every crafter isn't the same you have to choose a profession and fit that particular role.

[DNO]

Who said you can't speculate?
(1) This is not 11
(2) I think you are wrong.



Not sure if serious.... ^^

then tell me how using SE past and other intelligent means how SE would do it.

Since going off SE OWN PAST MMOS and the fact that Yoshi has/is adding everything from other MMOS so is not enough to make an educated guess.

[BloodLotus]

i think so also but if we tell them this is not what we want loud enough mab they will listen? they have before. And hey do not get me wrong if a dev comes in and says "this is the plan we need to do this for the betterment (is that a word) of the game then i will dead the tread and go on. But do not keep me in the dark and have me waste my time ranking up crafts i would never have touched.

I mean in all my MMO life i NEVER touched a craft before now since i can do lots in this game i actually started craft and having fun. You no what would kill my fun? If i can not get crafting to a max level one day.

If you compare timelines of when we get statements translated to when we hear official notes and they're implemented you'll see that when we get something translated it's pretty much set in stone. Polls really won't do anything.

Besides, this thread is premature. It shouldn't come out after we got an official statement.

But the original problem is that the first 3 posts are biased and inaccurate.

[BloodLotus]

then tell me how using SE past and other intelligent means how SE would do it.

Since going off SE OWN PAST MMOS and the fact that (1) Yoshi has/is adding everything from other MMOS so is not enough to make an educated guess.

(1) Like what?

Ok going off their past mmo (their only one) how many things are mechanically the same versus how many are mechanically different?

[Rinsui]

DNO,
using caps in every single one of your posts doesn't make you look any smarter.
Nor does making up biased polls.
Nor does repeating the same stuff in several threads.
Nor does ignoring punctuation and grammar.

[DNO]

If you compare timelines of when we get statements translated to when we hear official notes and they're implemented you'll see that when we get something translated it's pretty much set in stone. Polls really won't do anything.

Besides, this thread is premature. It shouldn't come out after we got an official statement.

But the original problem is that the first 3 posts are biased and inaccurate.

Its not premature

what first 3 post?

and nothing is accurate because we have no clue what they are limiting so your post is also inaccurate

[DNO]

DNO,
using caps in every single one of your posts doesn't make you look any smarter.
Nor does making up biased polls.
Nor does repeating the same stuff in several threads.
Nor does ignoring punctuation and grammar.

Ahh but going completely off topic makes you look smart?

TROLL (capps see it)

[DNO]

(1) Like what?

Ok going off their past mmo (their only one) how many things are mechanically the same versus how many are mechanically different?

ahhh a question with a question that is the age old way to debate good job.
I will only answer your post after you answer mine.

[BloodLotus]

ahhh a question with a question that is the age old way to debate good job.
I will only answer your post after you answer mine.

Then clarify your question.

[Raistlin]

But combat classes are producing items via drops.

and? Mercedes, BMW, etc if they want, they have materials to craft double or triple cars every day, but they need to control production on a competitive market.

If we had a car producer per 10 drivers... cars could cost 3000€ instead 20000 and producers will gain so low benefit that they will try it with worse (and cheaper) raw material.. etc etc etc, we will had 1 car per person and drive could be imposible on big cities. (just expeculation but probably near reallity) Economy is not as easy as let me sell and let they buy