Itemization in FFXI in unexciting

[Jynx]

In before you get torn apart for your thread title.

[Teslo]

In before you get torn apart for your thread title.

That's the only reason I'm here... :P lmao

Hey OP, it's an MMO. That's how these things work. 10% of the population always calls for MORE MORE HARDER HARDER (Not an innuendo...) and complains when things get nerfed so that the other 88% can play. That 88% wants everything handed to them, wants things to be easy, doesn't want to research their jobs or rotations, or plan out gear itemizations (I'm exaggerating a little). The remaining 2% is just "Yeah, whatever man. Just like... Play the game and chill, dude."

Also we ARE talking about XIV and not XI, right? :P Just *cough* checking!

[Mimilu]

One thing I have to say about the OP's #2, secondary stats do play a role.
Scholars require Crit. It makes our shields so much better.
Speed Spell is negative stat for Summoners because it ruins their DoT rotation.
White Mages and now Summoners enjoy having more Piety.

[Magis]

In before you get torn apart for your thread title.

Had to do a double take lol. OP might want to edit his title/post with a clarification. Anyway, I agree with him.