Thanks for the responses everyone. Yeah, I kinda figured I was right about a WAR being better for the group. Again, my only concern is that he DID join the group as PLD, and I don't feel very good about essentially demanding someone to switch to a job that they didn't originally intend to play. But again, it IS better for the group as a whole, and the biggest thing for me at the moment is having such an uncooperative person in the group.