White Mage vs Scholar - Why is White Mage lacking?

[DarkmoonVael]

Thank you for pointing out the obvious.

You are ignorant of the obvious, and this is why it is being pointed out to you. You seem to be on a little hate crusade against whm, and blinded by your own adamance that you are correct and everyone else is wrong. The fact that you argued this case for scholar, and refused to point out that the same can be done as whm under the circumstances i have shown reflect poorly on your judgement. Construct an argument that is balanced and you wont have these problems.

You neglected to mention anything at all about crowd control and how it fits into raids etc. Again, showing the inherent biased in your argument. These, once again, had to be pointed out to you. Yet your attitude, once again, is to try and change what HAS been discussed. YOU failed to talk about crowd control in your argument.

The issue is not others "failure to understand the mechanics in the fights you mentioned", but your utter selectiveness in what fights you are choosing to say whm is bad and scholar is awesome. The fact that you can only select 2 fights to try and proove your point shows how weak your arguments are. Try healing everyone after the mega flare with a scholar only and keep that tank alive - good luck here.

And now, the icing on the cake for you. How not to read what the person has written. You know, in academia, there are certain short hand phrases used to denote certain things. For example (sic) is used to denote a direct quotation where the original source has used an incorrect spelling of a word. This can be extended to the internet where the abbreviation iirc is used to denote where the principle of the statement is true, but one of the figures may be mildly out. Please learn how to understand these "complicated" meanings before you start debating with people.

Also, your arguments are so flawed, we dont have to do much research to disprove them. Your weakness here is showing.

EDIT: anyone with any experience with scholar will tell you that the fairies do not respond as fast as they would hope. They get animation locked, their A.I. locks them into healing someone else at times. You seem ignorant of this well known fact, yet you main scholar.