Is the guild mark restriction unreasonable?

[Kafeen]

I think its a reasonable request to make of people.

It makes sense that the guilds would be more likely to reward people in the areas they're based.
Classes aren't discriminated against as the same restrictions are applied to all classes.
I think its fair to ask players to travel in order to obtain the rewards they want.
It means players are going to me more likely to start moving their characters to Gridania and Limsa Lominsa rather than everyone gathering in Ul'dah.

[RabidSquirrel]

I think its a reasonable request to make of people.

It makes sense that the guilds would be more likely to reward people in the areas they're based.
Classes aren't discriminated against as the same restrictions are applied to all classes.
I think its fair to ask players to travel in order to obtain the rewards they want.
It means players are going to me more likely to start moving their characters to Gridania and Limsa Lominsa rather than everyone gathering in Ul'dah.

Not really what the OP is talking about, I don't think. The weaver guild is in Ul'dah, so that's not a problem. The problem is that sometimes there will be no leves that give guildmarks in a city. So if you're unlucky and there's no leves that give guild marks this leve cycle, then you're just boned. 'cause you certainly won't find any of them anywhere else.