just a quick fyi, i dont read every thread, let alone check the forums often, i usually just check the thread and see whats going on...so with that said

i really dont see why some of these changes are needed.

allowing wars to use rampart? warriors are more of a dps tank, able to do damage in comparison to the other tank available, you have a somewhat real dps combo you can use, pld doesnt have this at all. pld was originally designed to be mitigation

fix holmgang? i have to agree with sapphic, longer duration or more hp wont fix the issue if your hp is dropping to that point to begin with

change duration or amount recovered? the first problem is assuming it was supposed to replace a healer, its more of a supplement to what is currently there, not a replacement (kinda like the chocobo system currently)

i do agree they should change with the way berserk worked, like remove pacification when defiance is NOT on, so they can do more damage when they are not in an active tank role

sadly, i have played all the jobs in this game so far, and to be quite fair, as long as you dont have a shitty healer, war is pretty damn good....half these changes just seem unnecessary to me. war can hold hate much easier than a pld, and with the changes they made to inner beast and vengeance, can take damage fairly well (you just need to know when to use your abilities) and with an good healer, wont have much difficulty

and further more, war doesnt need anymore cross class abilities from gladiators till gladiator/paladin gets access to their overpower ability as far as im concerned