Mapping out Chocobo Dye

[Ravenloft]

Nope!

Sunset Orange + Plums = Pumpkin Orange

Edit : I don't know if I should have done that but I already fed it some apples to make it turn Sunset Orange again.

Well, since mine was a bust. Try AttacKat's advice with the berries?

[Randelmire]

Well, since mine was a bust. Try AttacKat's advice with the berries?

Well, that's the last option...

So far :
Sunset Orange + Apple = Blood Red
Sunset Orange + Berries = ??? (Let me guess, Pumpkin Orange!)
Sunset Orange + Valfruit = ??? (Probably Pumpkin Orange?)
Sunset Orange + anything else = Pumpkin Orange

[LyricalMelody]

Well, that's the last option...

So far :
Sunset Orange + Apple = Blood Red
Sunset Orange + Berries = ??? (Let me guess, Pumpkin Orange!)
Sunset Orange + Valfruit = ??? (Probably Pumpkin Orange?)
Sunset Orange + anything else = Pumpkin Orange

My friend, who is acting as one of my experimental subjects, did get Qiqirn Brown from Sunset Orange + Plums. Seems to be possible, but a lower chance.