Other Paladin stealing aggro

[silvach]

Like Silvach said he must have been using provoke. But what stance was he in? I've personally had more trouble maintaining aggro as a WAR with a PLD OT in Sword Oath than one with Shield Oath, also what accessories did he have? STR or VIT? While I don't know PLD fully with your ilvl difference you should have no problem getting aggro back after he grabbed it, as a WAR I always get aggro back even though someone used provoke as I usually have higher ilvl and STR accessories.

Well, the STR may help but the ilvl in weapon does the biggest difference. With that difference (ilvl55 to ilvl90) it's impossible to lose agro without OT using provoke.

[Krindor]

Well, the STR may help but the ilvl in weapon does the biggest difference. With that difference (ilvl55 to ilvl90) it's impossible to lose agro without OT using provoke.

I'm might be blind but I don't see OP mentioning the ilvl of the weapon and the other tank might have aimed for Curtana Zenith first meaning that they have the same weapon, and the 50-70 str difference if the other PLD was using STR accessories can show a difference.