My god, the ego tripping in this thread has been palpable.

I think people are forgetting that the Scholar is a diverse class, there are no "best" Scholars out there because there is no definitive way to play the class, as you may argue with other classes. There isn't a right or wrong time to use Eos or Selene for a particular instance. There are too many extenuating circumstances between the player, and his/her party, to have the go-to fairy for each instance.

For example, I tend to use Selene when I'm doing my Duty Roulette. However, sometimes I'll switch to Eos because I'm actually hindering some DPS who have problems managing TP/MP correctly, or when they will have trouble dodging AoEs and Whispering Dawn takes some of the stress from me. Same dungeon, but different parties require different handling.

Point is, get off your high horses and stop acting like there is the end-all-be-all of Fairy strategies because there are too many variables in this game for that to exist.