[dev1079][Poll] Do you want CAPPED dungeons, or uncapped?

[Petori]

The only good reason for not having a cap is that if for example R46 goes to R25 dungeon, gets capped at R25, kills dungeon mobs and gets the same SP amount as R25 would.

[Perrin_Aybarra]

The only good reason for not having a cap is that if for example R46 goes to R25 dungeon, gets capped at R25, kills dungeon mobs and gets the same SP amount as R25 would.

that is not a good reason to be against it. That person is still working for his SP, plus being level 46 even if he gets SP as a level 25 would, he still needs a lot more to reach level 47. So since he is actually working the at the same difficulty than if he was fighting level 46 mobs with him being level 46, I don't see why he shouldn't be rewarded the same SP.

[Petori]

that is not a good reason to be against it. That person is still working for his SP, plus being level 46 even if he gets SP as a level 25 would, he still needs a lot more to reach level 47. So since he is actually working the at the same difficulty than if he was fighting level 46 mobs with him being level 46, I don't see why he shouldn't be rewarded the same SP.

Because then that would mean people could only do R25 dungeon all the way through 25 to 50. Of course only if it would yield good SP in the first place which we don't know. So yes, it's not a good reason because we don't know about SP rates in dungeons. Should've given it more thought before posting, oh well.

[syntaxlies]

The only good reason for not having a cap is that if for example R46 goes to R25 dungeon, gets capped at R25, kills dungeon mobs and gets the same SP amount as R25 would.

a rank 45 should not be going to a rank 25 dungeon to get sp anyways imo

[Perrin_Aybarra]

Because then that would mean people could only do R25 dungeon all the way through 25 to 50. Of course only if it would yield good SP in the first place which we don't know. So yes, it's not a good reason because we don't know about SP rates in dungeons. Should've given it more thought before posting, oh well.

Well we don't know how good the SP would be but to be fair we know that we can only do it once a day a per a rep's post somewhere not sure where anymore. So SPing in those dungeons would only be valid for 60min per day and to be honest, people should be entitled to SP the way they want, it's just one more way to do it. Not everyone enjoys the leves and behest (wait almost no one does since they are so boring) :P

[Petori]

a rank 45 should not be going to a rank 25 dungeon to get sp anyways imo

Yet some people leveled up till cap in dunes in FFXI.

[syntaxlies]

this is obviously going nowhere.

[Richard]

this is obviously going nowhere.

Both uncapped vs capped threads served there purpose. Look at the poll count, vote if you'd like and then put foot in mouth. SE isn't going to ignore it and when they tweak the dungeons after more community feedback things will have a good chance to be changed to optional capped content. Goal achieved.

[TheVedis]

Why shouldn't they? It's 1 of the 2 major contents we have gotten in 9 months and they should not enjoy it how it was supposed to?

its not "how its supposed to"
its how "you want us to"

theres a BIG difference

[TheVedis]

Again not everything is about YOU. If all your classes are at 50 but you want to help a friend lower level without ruining the learning experience and the challenge for them, what do you do?

no its not all about me

apperently its all about YOU
and how YOU want to make others experience the content

if YOU want to do it at 30, do it at 30

but you are telling others they have to do it your way, cuz thats how YOU want them to do it

YOU dont want them to choose how to do it