First - said it was slapped together so how about instead of just being destructive why not actually make suggestions?

Yes I left numbers intentionally weak as a baseline.

Not once in an mmo (spanning 17 years) has having a specialty tank negated others unless it was broken like NIN. IMO having a strength vs one def while being weak to another wouldn't negate Pal or War at all. Versatile vs specialist. Specially as stated you keep it within reason.

The riposte attacks at 100/125 potency is weak. Its combo starter DMG not finisher so the threat modifiers aren't as out of line. Also with baseline 1.5 threat vs 1 of a DPS it is a way to use the job mechanic as threat builder.

Yes screwed up Riposte as it is more trait then skill.


As for lvl 45 Arcane Lance thought was to allow the job something so it wouldn't be useless outside of exceptional magic heavy fights and allow light to moderate magic fights a chance. Again without exclusion.

Your also right the HP is low, but rather start low and tweak then suggest overpowered crap like I usually see.

So suggestions or just be negative?