Can't believe this is thread is still going in.

A healer that only heals and everyone lives, is a good healer, period end of story.

A healer that keeps everyone alive and DPSs speeding up the run and thus making things faster and reducing risk of pain because of shorter fights is a great healer.

The only thing that makes a healer bad is they they ignore healing so they can DPS. However, a tank does not need to be at 100% HP for 100% of the time except maybe in coil. This not being at 100% should not make anyone think the healer isn't doing their job.

Again, A healer that doesn't DPS but keeps everyone alive even if they are just standing around is a good healer.