I can confirm the claim that SMN and MNK do really well in T5. From my experience, it is almost always me and a monk competing for the #1 spot in T5, assuming the monk knows what they are doing. We do not have a monk in my static and I do not often get to play with good monks, but the one time we had to pug a melee I was super impressed.

It's really hard to judge a job based on their overall damage/dps because, as Sleigh said, SMN will naturally come ahead because of their DoT spreads and the damage that ticks while they are dodging. What I like to see is where people spike and when. Useful dps is more important to me than overall dps/damage. Most importantly, I think the use of parsers should be constructive (not just an arbitrary way to say who is better)... One example would be my static group... One of our members was not pulling their weight in dps, so we were able to (politely) bring it up and they were able to practice and improve, no feelings hurt. We were frequently hitting the hard enrage timer prior to him bringing his dps up to speed, but we one shot it last week. We complimented him on his increased damage and he mentioned he had been practicing on a dummy.