Suggestion for new style for 8-man dungeon

[Espon]

I don't know of any MMO that rewards you for perfect clear one shots. The whole point is to try new ways to do things like that 6 scholar 2 tank titan extreme fight. The current game design doesn't encourage slop play unless you're cheesing turn 2 and by all means good luck with turn 5.

WoW actually did this for a bit when they introduced the Trial of the Crusader raid. You were given 50 wipes to clear the place, and depending on how well you did would determine what you find in the bonus chest at the end. Clearing it with all 50 wipes unused would get you the best gear, and if no one died, your entire group would also be awarded a mount.

Needless to say, it didn't go over well with the community since you can't always control when wipes happen (such as disconnects or server hiccups), thus preventing you from the best loot for that week... not to mention sometimes mistakes just happen. It didn't help that the final boss extremely unforgiving and one of the hardest in the expansion, either. They elected not to include this feature in future raids unless it was just for an achievement. I rather not see something similar in this game.