What is "questionable" about that entry?

Going by the very guidelines YOU posted in your initial complaint.

The screenshot must be taken by the user submitting. Check.
Please do not submit images of only NPCs or backgrounds. Check number two.
Make sure you character is visible in the screenshot. Check number tres.
You may not use image editing software to alter, enhance or add more features to your screenshot. Check number bingo bango bobbity boom.

So what is questionable about it then? The only thing you bothered saying about it was whether it "shows great effort went in".

You got upset because you didn't win. You went through every single entry nitpicking for an imaginary instance of SE breaking their rules. You accuse one of the winners of using photoshop to win and when confronted with direct evidence against that claim instead of admitting you may have been wrong and accepting the loss you go on the defensive over being "one upped" and decide to start questioning winners over their perceived "effort" compared to your glorious submission.

If you can't pick out where along that series of events you should have grown up then here's a hint... it's everywhere...