Wow, one of the best guild descriptions I have ever read. By first referring to your FC as a college frat and then following with such a meaningful description, which stands in direct conflict with the "frat" expectation, you provided a greater depth of understanding to the makeup of your guild than could otherwise have been achieved. So I thank you for that.

I should perhaps say, my interest in getting into endgame is the experience that comes with participating in endgame and not the items I acquire, that is, the experience of working with a group of people to overcome a shared objective. My problem as of late with FFXIV, and the reason that I posted here, was that I was missing that shared sense of accomplishment and camaraderie that comes with guild membership. But of course, your descriptions of Onion and Rodeo make it same like I can achieve what I am looking for in either guild and now I have no clue which to choose.