The state of monks in PvP

[Zabuza]

I agree 100% that kiting is our biggest problem, and GL is the worst class mechanic in PvP. I'm just not sure on the best way to fix them.

If we don't have enough mobility we're weak, but with too much mobility we will be overpowered. Adding a snare is probably the biggest mobility change SE could make because it benefits the whole team. Heavy Resistance to Fist of Wind would benefit only MNK, so I think (properly tuned) it may be a more balanced option.

The snare may make double melee dps teams powerful, true. However I do believe we absolutely need a ranged attack for some form of damage while we're being kited, every other dps class has one, even DRG.

[LongNu]

If MNK / DRG gets a snare, they will be on par with the other DPS classes. Not overpowered. On par.

[mirth12]

I have seen a couple decent MNK's on my data center. I can't remember their names now, but one is using Allegan weapons O.o When played correctly they are a scary foe that brings a lot of burst. Although I haven't played the class, I can say that most teams I have faced with a MNK seem to fall off after their initial burst. MNK/MNK/MRD teams global me in full i90 no matter the heals does. Melee dps seems like they will benefit the most from i90 morale gear, but I never see one that has taken the time to rank up

[Zabuza]

If MNK / DRG gets a snare, they will be on par with the other DPS classes. Not overpowered. On par.

It's necessary with how the server handles lag and stuff, even with them lowering the delay I still sometimes miss attacks while right on someone.

I have seen a couple decent MNK's on my data center. I can't remember their names now, but one is using Allegan weapons O.o When played correctly they are a scary foe that brings a lot of burst. Although I haven't played the class, I can say that most teams I have faced with a MNK seem to fall off after their initial burst. MNK/MNK/MRD teams global me in full i90 no matter the heals does. Melee dps seems like they will benefit the most from i90 morale gear, but I never see one that has taken the time to rank up

Because all the burst comes from their skill perfect balance... which is on a 3 minute cooldown... So they can normally only burst 1 time per match, which is my gripe. You either kill a target during that one window or it's over.

[Katiklysm]

I have seen a couple decent MNK's on my data center. I can't remember their names now, but one is using Allegan weapons O.o When played correctly they are a scary foe that brings a lot of burst. Although I haven't played the class, I can say that most teams I have faced with a MNK seem to fall off after their initial burst. MNK/MNK/MRD teams global me in full i90 no matter the heals does. Melee dps seems like they will benefit the most from i90 morale gear, but I never see one that has taken the time to rank up

Can I be one of the decent MNK's mirth? (Desirae Starfire) mirth plz!

on topic- I don't think MNK needs a single arena buff. Our pvp skills + fists of wind gives everything you should need, more would be beyond OP. The real problem is Miasma and SE has already commented on bringing SCH/SMN into line. A nerf there would be a true buff to MNK (and DRG). Axe Kick is possibly the best arena skill in game.

[Zabuza]

Can I be one of the decent MNK's mirth? (Desirae Starfire) mirth plz!

on topic- I don't think MNK needs a single arena buff. Our pvp skills + fists of wind gives everything you should need, more would be beyond OP. The real problem is Miasma and SE has already commented on bringing SCH/SMN into line. A nerf there would be a true buff to MNK (and DRG). Axe Kick is possibly the best arena skill in game.

Yes, miasma makes it pretty much useless when it is on me. I believe monk benefits the most from their PvP abilities as well, seems like it starts kinda bad and then gets better the more PvP skills you get, they all seem to be highly useful. You're a rank 30 Monk right?

[Katiklysm]

Because all the burst comes from their skill perfect balance... which is on a 3 minute cooldown... So they can normally only burst 1 time per match, which is my gripe. You either kill a target during that one window or it's over.

Perfect Balance is an "Oops" button (or potentially to faster ramp up dps), it has very little to do with burst. 9 out of 10 matches I use PB to squeeze more damage into the tank at the end for commendation consideration, rarely used at any critical point in the fight.

For Burst: See the 4-5 Off GCD's at your disposal.

[Katiklysm]

Yes, miasma makes it pretty much useless when it is on me. I believe monk benefits the most from their PvP abilities as well, seems like it starts kinda bad and then gets better the more PvP skills you get, they all seem to be highly useful. You're a rank 30 Monk right?

I wish =) Still a long ways to go, i70pvp+i95 weapon- ah, I just saw you were on Zalera- thought the name looked familiar.

[Mitski]

No guarantee that planned adjustments to SMN/SCH will affect Miasma's heavy Adjustments to the healing debuff and pet damage/healing seem more likely.

[Zabuza]

Perfect Balance is an "Oops" button (or potentially to faster ramp up dps), it has very little to do with burst. 9 out of 10 matches I use PB to squeeze more damage into the tank at the end for commendation consideration, rarely used at any critical point in the fight.

For Burst: See the 4-5 Off GCD's at your disposal.

I usually use it for burst and to get 3 stacks of GL early. It's either that or take 20 seconds worth of GCDs to get 3 stacks.

No guarantee that planned adjustments to SMN/SCH will affect Miasma's heavy Adjustments to the healing debuff and pet damage/healing seem more likely.

Which actually annoys me greatly, since Miasma is so broken.