Quote Originally Posted by Raestloz View Post
SNIP
Have you solo-healed Titan HM yet in a PUG? Or even just healed Ultima in a PUG with non-dodging DPS...there's a reason I'm tanking that fight and not healing it anymore

And no, tanks don't have to know the instance any more than DPS or heals do. A tank can be perfect, but if a Heal or DPS pulls extra mobs because they don't know a trigger or see the coming mob, is it really the tank's fault? Haukke N is a good one where you see DPS/Heals pulling things and causing wipes a LOT. I've also seen a lot more wipes caused by heals who don't know a dungeon than tanks who don't.

Also, for Garuda HM...people should NOT be standing near Garuda during a sisters phase at all...its their fault if they get stunned at those times. You see where she spawns and where she's going, and there's plenty of room to avoid her attacks. The only thing tanks really need to know with that fight is where to pull her during movement phases.