So this thread sums up to: "Waaaah I don't like PvP because another player might expose how bad I am at the game, don't implement it SE so that PvP fans can't have fun and we can all fight easy monsters together AS FRIENDS."

If you don't like PvP, then why bother posting in the thread? It's not as if you would be FORCED to participate. Back on topic, here are my only expectations for PvP if it's ever implemented:

1. Team based. Get that hurr 1v1 duel i pwn u nonsense out of here.
2. Objective based. Shouldn't be PURELY about killing each other.
3. Balanced seperately. FFXI did this pretty well after a while (in 60 caps at least). A WS that does consistent 1k+ damage in a PvE setting should obviously be toned down to deal like 500-ish during PvP.