Has SE screwed itself?

[Exstal]

So from reading the last few pages, here's what I've gathered;

-PGL is less likely to be a tank because you have to rework everything about it
-Sniper (a DPS class), would not be exactly like Bard because their class abilities are different
-Evasion tanking sucks

Now, since I've taken a gander at those topics let's try to simplify it heavily for those who get crit by walls of text

1. PGL tank
- add emnity to skills randomly across the board
- tweak stat allocation akin to SMN/SCH to achieve similiar HP to WAR/PLD
- positional requirements need to go as it'd be impossible to do from a tank standpoint

2. Sniper
Not much to say on this. From what I saw, it's just a Bard without songs. So why not just give these job skills to Bard and make it only usable in a certain stance (Sniper Stance)?

3. This has been beaten to death. It's also been theorycrafted on how it could be awesome. Just look around and you'll find it.