Paladin is the better tank, but Warrior is the better class

[Uliq]

Under perfect conditions I just don't see Warrior being capable of OutDPSing Paladin at all even if I were to Pop Berserk, Brutal Swing on CD, Unchained on CD and Inner Beast on Fury. And the disparity widens when they are asked to DPS as OT. One will not toggle Berserk and can only use Inner Beast every 60 seconds, whilst the other gains 20% auto attack damage with no strings attached.

I wanted to argue this but there is no factor that disproves this. As OT the WAR can go either Defiance or no Defiance and it's damage wouldn't change much. It loses it's wrath, which is crit % and an added attack through IB or damage loss negation through Unchained, to swap out a 25% damage increase. Overtime neither using Defiance or not matters and it's only cross-class ability that would help OT is the MNK's IR, so... I'm handing you the win.