I would have no problem with this...as long as they get scale armor and stay off that hideous trash can stuff. As a Red Mage, gotta do your thing with style. I'm generally not into tanking, but I would play Red Mage if it were like this, though I think it should be DPS with some supportive stuff, with the core class possibly something akin to Spellblade from Tactics A2 but using raipiers mainhand and a gauche offhand for an extra attack and/or additional parry chance, like fencers of old did with.Come to think of it Red Mage could make a very interesting high risk/high reward tank. Sword/raiper for base combat, melee based fire/ice/thunder spells for damage moves, and a setup of highly situational buffs/debuffs/self heals for mitigation. A regain for sustained damage, a short lived mass armor buff for power attacks, a debuff for toning down AOE spam, that kind of stuff.
Make it the hard to play but unstoppable when played right tank class.
Dark Knight, heavy DPS. The core class for it can be Lanista, taken from FF Tactics A2, which plays similar to a Dark Knight, weapon being Great Sword. Dark Knight at least should be able to use plate armor as an option.
Samurai could be a tank. Parivir could be the core class, being derived from the Indian term Parivrajaka, a subclass of the merchant caste known to take bodyguard jobs.
For Ninja...I believe Thief should be the class for the Ninja job. It was that way in the first FF, and Edge in FF IV was a ninja but had the token Thief ability "Steal".
True, which is why I think they should be able to use plate armors like the tanks BECAUSE they're going to have an ability like Souleater which will drain HP to do more damage and the like.i'd like to see SAM be a tank and DRK be a balls-to-the-wall glass melee DPS. DRK being even remotely associated with tanking would make me such a sad panda, a class with a history of having it's signature abilities sacrifice HP/defenses to deal more damage has no business ever being imagined as a tank, imo. warrior is already a drain tank.